Is this by design?

I had this strange thought today about why civilizations seem to rise, advance and eventually destroy themselves.

Imagine creation has a finite amount of resources and time. If you wanted those resources to produce the greatest possible variety of outcomes, perhaps having one civilization arise and eventually occupy everything forever wouldn't achieve that. Instead, civilizations could have an inherent tendency toward self-destruction. One rises, develops knowledge and technology, reaches enormous complexity and power, eventually collapses, and makes room for something else to arise. Each civilization becomes almost another iteration of what intelligent life can become.

The self-destruct wouldn't necessarily be some literal timer built into creation. It could simply be a consequence of intelligence itself. As intelligence increases, technological power increases. Greater power creates greater complexity and also greater ability to cause catastrophic damage. Eventually a civilization may acquire the ability to destroy itself faster than it acquires the wisdom to prevent itself from doing so.

So I started wondering: what if this repeated cycle of civilizations isn't a flaw in creation? What if rise, advancement, collapse and replacement are actually part of how creation works?

But then I ran straight into a theological problem with my own idea.

I'm thinking about this as a Muslim, so I believe in a Creator who is all-knowing and self-sufficient. Allah doesn't need anything from His creation. So I can't say that He creates successive civilizations as an "experiment" to find out what His creation is capable of. If He is all-knowing, He already knows every possible outcome. There is nothing for Him to discover.

And that led me to a much bigger question.

Maybe creation isn't about God discovering what His creation will do at all. Maybe it is about possibilities that are already completely known to God actually becoming lived realities for the created beings themselves.

God doesn't need to discover the story.

We do.

I don't know where this idea goes yet, but that's the rabbit hole my brain decided to enter today. 😂

Then I started thinking about where the afterlife fits into all of this.

And that changes the idea quite a bit.

If I look at it from an Islamic perspective, civilizations cannot really be the ultimate point of the process. Civilizations rise and disappear, but according to Islam the individuals within them don't simply cease to exist. Death ends their participation in this physical world, not their existence.

So perhaps I was looking at the wrong unit. Maybe civilizations are not the subjects of the process at all. They are the environments in which conscious beings live and exercise their choices.

Someone lives 5,000 years ago in one kind of civilization. I live today in an entirely different one. Someone thousands of years from now might live in circumstances we cannot even imagine. Civilizations, technologies and societies change, but conscious beings continue to face choices within whatever world they inherit.

That also connects back to the problem of God's omniscience. If Allah already knows what every person will do, then earthly life cannot be an experiment conducted so that God can discover the result.

Perhaps the point is not for God to discover our choices, but for us to actually make them.

Knowing that someone will choose something is different from that person actually living through the circumstances and making that choice. Life makes those possibilities into an actual history for the person who experiences it.

And then the afterlife provides the continuation that my original idea was missing. A civilization may disappear, but the human beings who lived within it are not simply discarded when their particular version of the world ends.

But there is an important boundary here that I don't want to blur.

The first part of my thought started with things we can physically observe: civilizations rise and fall, species appear and become extinct, resources are finite, technology increases both our abilities and our capacity to destroy ourselves. From those observations I can speculate about whether rise, complexity and eventual collapse might be a recurring feature of intelligent civilizations.

But the moment I introduce a Creator's intention, and especially the afterlife, I've moved beyond what I can physically observe.

Now I am in the realm of philosophy, revelation and faith.

That doesn't invalidate the thought. It just means I shouldn't pretend that both parts are the same kind of argument.

Science might someday tell us a great deal about why civilizations collapse and perhaps even whether technological civilizations have a natural tendency toward self-destruction.

But science cannot tell me why existence itself exists, what its ultimate purpose is, or what happens after death.

That's where my observation ends and my faith begins.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

میرے بھائی منور احمد ندیم

The Changing Face of Hypocrisy

Looking back at May28 2010 Ahmadi Massacre